Appalachian State (3-3, 1-1 Sun Belt) @ Old Dominion (3-3, 2-1 Sun Belt)
Saturday, October 21st, 2023 7:00pm EST
TV/Video: NFL Network
Radio: FLAGSHIP 97.3 FM (North Wilkesboro), 96.5
FM/1450 AM (Boone), 99.1 FM/1060 AM/1030 AM (Charlotte),
105.3 FM/1320 AM (Greensboro), 790 AM (Johnson City),
107.7 FM/1450 AM (Hendersonville), 103.9FM/1250AM (Marion), Varsity Network App
Kornblau Field at S.B. Ballard Stadium
Capacity: 21,944
Surface: Fieldturf
Jeff Sagarin Ratings
App State: 69.27
Coastal Carolina: 59.13
Home: 2.43
App State is favored by the Sagarin ratings by 7.71 points
VegasInsider Line: App State -6.5
Series: App State leads 3-0
Last Meeting: App State 27, Old Dominion 14, November 19, 2022, Boone, NC
The field goal giveth, and the field goal taketh away. In the third straight game, the kicking game became the difference in a football game. It’s been an up and down journey. The insanity of September 2022 decided make a make a curtain call in 2023, and is stretching the applause clear into October. No mistaking, its been a wild time to be a fan. With each passing week of close games, decided by a play or two, some doubt starts to creep into everyone’s thoughts. It’s impossible to block it all out. It might be one of the most difficult parts of anyone’s job, questioning if they can make it work like they had hoped. Tough times never last. Eventually it end’s one direction or another. Many conference champions have been decided with a conference loss on their resume. Sometimes even with multiple losses. The leaves are turning in the High Country, but they have not fallen yet. There is a lot of football season left, and everyone in the Sun Belt East has a chance.
Where does one start with the Monarchs? This group might be the most confusing team to figure out in the Sun Belt. Old Dominion has played a schedule that one can categorize as semi-difficult. They have played two ACC teams in Virginia Tech and Wake Forest. They trailed the Hokies at half by six points on opening weekend, but could not find any offense in the second half, before falling 36-17. Two weeks later, they led Wake Forest 17-0 at half, and 24-7 deep into the third quarter before allowing the Deacons to score the final 20 points of the game, losing 27-24. In two games against Sun Belt opponents, both were high scoring affairs, with the Monarchs throwing the ball all over Louisiana, and running it all over Marshall. And the final two games, against Southern Miss and Texas A&M-Commerce, were low scoring matchups, and were decided in the fourth quarter. All of this to describe a team that can play with P5’s, can play against above average conference opponents, but can also struggle with some very bad teams.
Grant Wilson and Jack Shields have both played five games for Monarchs at quarterback. The problem is the Monarchs have played six games. It was Wilson who went 13/19 for a season high 247 yards with 4 touchdown passes in the win over Louisiana. Wilson did not play against Marshall, which left Shields to open the scoring on a 66 yard touchdown run in the opening minute. Shields also threw three interceptions against the Herd in a game where the Monarchs ran for 356 yards and somehow still lost. Both quarterbacks complete just a hair over 50% of their passes and have combined for 9 touchdown passes and 8 interceptions. Excluding one game here and there makes those numbers look increasingly different. Take away those 4 TD passes against Louisiana, and that TD/INT ratio looks downright ugly. The same can be said about the three interception game against Marshall. That ratio becomes tolerable. So which quarterback shows on up on Saturday?
It’s been so long since last Tuesday night, and quite honestly, revisiting any of still seems too fresh on the mind. The major concern is obvious. Nate Noel carried the ball one time, gained a yard, and left the game. The most recent update to his ankle is that he is still under evaluation. Coach speak this all you want, but based on the current information, he’s likely a game time decision. That leaves the running game in the hands of several backs who could see an increased role. Kanye Roberts was the only Mountaineer running back to break ten carries after Noel’s departure, and could see an increased role. It’s also possible that Roberts does not see Noel-like distribution and this backfield becomes a true committee. Roberts has been the most effective, with 5.5 yards per carry, with just thirty carries on the year.
The Mountaineer defense has now gone three straight weeks giving up a big play or multiple plays. You could even sprinkle in a play or two from ECU and UNC, but those did not hurt the Apps like they last three weeks felt. Wyoming’s big run negated the Mountaineers pick six. Monroe, out of literally nowhere, completed big pass play after big pass play, and Coastal followed suit. At first these plays trickled in, and then last week, it felt like an avalanche. Enter Old Dominion, whose offense cannot move the chains, hold the ball or convert third downs, but you know what they can do? They can hit the big play. Ten of their sixteen offensive touchdown plays have travelled 30 yards or more. There is no greater lesson about keeping your gaps minded and staying on top of the ball than what the Mountaineers will see this weekend.
After several weeks of dealing with similar issues on the defensive side of the ball, App State will have to gear up for a team that sticks to their plan of finding weaknesses to exploit when they are on offense. Despite this trend becoming the norm of late, it’s a topic that coaches bring up weekly to their players. In some cases, you may not have the horses to stop it, and in other scenarios, it’s all about positioning, which can always be corrected. We’ve mentioned these explosive plays as the way that Old Dominion has scored more than half of their offensive touchdowns. Keep in mind those sixteen scores have come in six games, which means they are scoring less than three touchdowns per game. The Monarchs have only had six other scoring “drives” this season. Putting this all together, Old Dominion is incredibly inefficient on offense. They average close to six yards a play, outgaining their opponents by nearly a full yard per play, yet are outgained by about twenty yards a game in total offense, while also being dominated in time of possession by close to 13 minutes a game. Still, they have played in five straight one score games. This matchup is a reminder that what you see in box scores and stat sheets can lead you astray from the actual product on the field. The way the Mountaineers have also played in four games decided by one possession might lead one to believe that we could be heading down the same road again. If you are rooting for App State, how must they avoid a repeat of past performances? I believe this all comes down to covering your assignments. As much as we have discussed how Old Dominion thrives on the big play, over the course of a game, they are still very inconsistent. The focus of the App State defense should be on winning each series. On the other side of the ball, the Mountaineers must find a way to consistently run the football. The Monarchs have yet to surrender a 100-yard rusher on defense to a running back. The only player to do so, was Marshall quarterback Cam Fancher. The defensive alignment tricks offensive coordinators into running, but the Monarchs remain in pursuit. The best way to get safeties away from the line of scrimmage is to open the passing game up. Old Dominion has been burned repeatedly by competent passing offenses, which excludes Southern Miss and Texas A&M-Commerce. A steady dose and Aguilar and company should put the Monarchs on their heels enough for a close win for the Mountaineers.
The First Pick:
Royals 23
Mountaineers 31